If there's one province that simply won't stand for arrogance in its
politicians, you'd think it would be Alberta.
Pierre Trudeau, who couldn't even escape the venom in the immediate days
following his death, found that out the hard way. So, too, did Brian
Mulroney, who made the fatal mistake of taking his Western votes for
granted and wound up spawning the Reform Party. And it hardly needs
pointing out that, if Jean Chretien is looking for a friendly vacation
spot anytime soon, he'd probably be best to look somewhere other than
Banff or Jasper.
What boggles the mind, then, is that the province continues to put up
with Ralph Klein.
In fairness, there's some grousing emerging from Alberta about the
rather blatant way in which the Premier is now just going through the
motions. Former supporters bemoan his lackadaisical approach to his job,
his apparent disinterest in the sorts of radical policies that he built
a national reputation on, and a forthcoming bid for a fourth straight
mandate that will serve no purpose other than to feed his ego. But on
the evidence of what the rest of us saw from him this week, Mr. Klein
has gotten off far too easy.
Five years ago, Mr. Chretien made the foolish decision to skip King
Hussein of Jordan's funeral in favour of continuing his skiing vacation.
His excuse that he couldn't get there from Whistler in time was
particularly lame, and his subsequent apology seemed forced and
insincere. Quite rightly, he was pilloried both across the country and
abroad - and particularly by critics in Western Canada who couldn't
stand him in the first place.
Now, let's pretend that Mr. Chretien had instead pulled what Mr. Klein
did at this week's federal-provincial health summit. Suppose he had
skipped out on an event with a significant impact upon his government's
ability to perform its number one priority - one that actually affects
the lives of Canadians - rather than the funeral of a foreign leader.
Suppose he had tried to work it to his advantage, claiming that the
event would be a "gong show" and then doing his utmost to turn it into
just that. Suppose that, on the one evening he deigned to spend at the
three-day event, he had bailed out early on an important dinner in
favour of the local casino. And, just to cap it off, pretend that all
this was justified on the basis that he had to head off to a love-in
with deep-pocketed supporters because there were "no bloody votes" to be
had at the summit.
Most likely, it would have ended with many of Mr. Chretien's own caucus
members - perhaps even a few who weren't previously out to dethrone him
- calling for his resignation. And that, in a province where no other
party has any reasonable chance at forming government, is precisely what
Mr. Klein's MLAs should be doing.
At a conference at which none of the participants covered themselves in
glory, Mr. Klein's performance stood out as a particular embarrassment
- not just to himself, but to the voters who will almost certainly hand
him another mandate before the end of the calendar year.
To leave his province as the only one insufficiently represented at this
week's talks was an affront to every Albertan taxpayer. Mr. Klein's
defenders would contend that Alberta's interests would have been ignored
anyway - that the conference would inevitably have focused almost
exclusively on throwing cash (including equalization dollars) at poorer
provinces. But how he helped matters by turning that into a
self-fulfilling prophecy, refusing even to attempt to represent
Alberta's interests, will remain a mystery.
It's not just Albertans who should be furious. For years, conservatives
nationwide have heralded Mr. Klein as the only premier with sufficient
moxie to challenge the health care status quo. For them, it must be
particularly galling that he passed up a prime opportunity to do that so
he could take refuge with his friends back home - not to mention that
his only real contribution during his brief drop-in at the conference
was to demand that Ottawa inject somewhere between $65- and $100-billion
into the system.
Once upon a time, Mr. Klein's name was seriously bandied about as a
potential leader for the federal united right. In his present
incarnation, it's hard to imagine most Conservatives would have him. And
if they applied the same standard to him as they do to federal
politicians, neither would most Albertans.