When Canada was teetering on the brink of separation in the 1990s,
reeling from one nail-biter referendum and facing the possibility of
another, the federal Liberals were smart enough to listen to Stephane
Dion.
Now, with Adscam and a growing list of regional tensions threatening
national unity again, they'd do well to listen to the former
Intergovernmental Affairs minister once more.
Meeting with the National Post editorial board yesterday, mostly to
discuss Ottawa's Kyoto plans in his capacity as Environment Minister,
the father of the Clarity Act was asked what he made of the recent
handwringing over Quebec's purportedly reinvigorated sovereignty
movement. Mr. Dion's response was ostensibly aimed at Stephen Harper and
Jack Layton, but it should speak just as loudly to Liberals.
"To me, unity is above partisan politics," Mr. Dion said. "We should not
encourage the mentality that if you have a disagreement with the
government of the day, if you don't like the Premier or the Prime
Minister, if you are mad because of the last scandal, then it makes
sense to put your loyalties to the country on the table. This is a
mistake. Other countries don't do it, but in Canada we're always doing
it."
To try to use the separatist threat to bully the public or other
politicians, Mr. Dion suggested, is a dangerous game: "It [reminds] me
of Mulroney during Meech Lake. He was saying ... 'sign, sign, otherwise
Quebecers may separate.' And then Quebecers were [saying] 'If the Prime
Minister is saying to us we should separate, maybe we should.'"
Perhaps he really was just talking about the Conservatives and the NDP.
But if so, it would mean Mr. Dion has tuned out the wave of Liberal
ministers who've spent the past weeks cautioning Canadians that
defeating them in the next election would - wait for it - increase the
risk of Quebec separating.
The claim this past weekend from Joe Volpe, the Immigration Minister and
Paul Martin's Ontario lieutenant, that "Stephen Harper is a more ardent
provincialist and separatist than even Gilles Duceppe" was so absurd
that it's almost not worth taking seriously. But more lucid offerings
from other Liberals - including Public Works Minister Scott Brison, the
point-man on Adscam damage control - suggest the party's campaign
strategy will be to paint a Conservative government as the first step
toward a oui vote.
So now, we've got Quebecers effectively being told by the Conservatives
and the NDP (along with the Bloc Quebecois, but that goes without
saying) that the federal government's behaviour has given them reason to
consider separating, and the Liberals telling them that the mere
election of a different government may also give them reason to head for
the hills.
It's a scenario that should give Mr. Dion nightmares: Federalists from
all sides pouring gasoline on sovereignty's heretofore flickering flame.
Already, Liberal premiers of Quebec tend to complain so much about
Ottawa that they create the impression that even federalists don't think
confederation is working. But at least they could argue it's the only
way they'll get elected over the real nationalists.
Federal politicians don't even have that excuse: Pure opportunism is the
only reason they're willing to put separatism on the table.
Unfortunately, that seems to be reason enough for most of Mr. Dion's
colleagues.