Of all the models political staffers would follow, you'd think Ezra
Levant would be pretty low down the list.
Now settled into a much better fit as publisher of the Western Standard
magazine, Mr. Levant was a disaster in his brief stint as communications
director for Stockwell Day. And while there were plenty of reasons for
that, the biggest was the degree to which he made himself the story.
Remember all the interviews and profiles, with the self-described
"Stockaholic" delightedly basking in the spotlight? The constant
attempts to publicly settle his own scores through the media? The
unwillingness to settle into the background and let his boss - who, for
all his flaws, was still a more appealing face for the party - take
centre stage?
In his defence, Ezra's job required him to talk to the media;
he just went about it the wrong way. Which is more than can be said for
Tim Murphy.
Mr. Murphy's name has been in the papers a lot lately, mostly because of
the peculiar - and still unresolved - Gurmant Grewal saga. But at
least that hasn't been of his own choosing. What's more bizarre is the
way that, in a fashion all too characteristic of Paul Martin's staffers,
the Prime Minister's chief of staff has put his boss' interests second
by stepping into the spotlight.
In last Saturday's Toronto Star, Susan Delacourt's account of the
Liberals' celebrations following their near-death non-confidence
experience painted an overall picture of a party that still hadn't
learned the lesson in humility it's so desperately in need of. But
particularly grotesque was the image of Mr. Murphy dancing atop a set of
speakers with Belinda Stronach - to the tune of Material Girl, no less,
quite possibly the last song in the world that Ms. Stronach or anybody
around her should have been rump-shaking to last week.
For very good reasons, this is not how senior, experienced political
staffers - let alone the most powerful man in the Prime Minister's
Office - are supposed to act. Most would have gone home to do their
celebrating, or retired to a quiet corner of a bar to raise a glass with
a few colleagues. But clearly, Mr. Murphy wanted everyone to know just
who was behind the deal with Ms. Stronach that helped keep the
government alive - as evidenced by another story in the Star the day
after Ms. Delacourt's ran.
Running under the headline "The Man Who (Really) Saved the Government,"
Graham Fraser's profile of Mr. Murphy was weirdly effusive - lauding
his "earnest idealism," and downplaying the Grewal mess on the basis
that "nobody who has been surreptitiously taped emerges from the
experience looking good." But what made the piece particularly strange
was that Mr. Murphy went on the record for it.
At one point, he's described raising his voice and banging his finger on
the table as he rails against criticism of the Liberals' recent
political manoeuvring. At another, he "impatiently" and "contemptuously"
attacks civil servants. And in a lengthy outline of his political
history, Mr. Fraser reports that Mr. Murphy supported Mr. Martin's 1990
leadership bid because he was "somewhat disillusioned with Pierre
Trudeau's vision of federalism and the economy."
Are showing contempt for the Liberals' critics, dismissing civil
servants' complaints and taking issue with Trudeau federalism all
consistent with the message the PM wants to convey? Who knows. But
whatever the case, why on earth would a chief of staff - or any other
aide - publicly speak out on such controversial subjects?
Whatever his other flaws, Jean Pelletier was almost never seen in public
when he was running Jean Chrétien's office. Don Guy, Dalton McGuinty's
chief of staff and quite possibly the most powerful person in Ontario,
doesn't just neglect to seek out the spotlight - he actively avoids it.
Like most other backroom titans, at least in this country, they've known
better than to cloud their bosses' public images by competing with them
for attention.
Whether or not Mr. Murphy is preparing himself for a run for public
office (as Mr. Fraser suggests in his article based on conversations
with other sources), he's behaving rather selfishly. Unfortunately, it's
conduct that's consistent with some other members of Mr. Martin's inner
circle - notably David Herle, the longtime advisor and campaign
co-chair, whose brash statements and combative public demeanour caused
the Liberals considerable headaches before he toned it down.
Mr. Murphy would do well to likewise rein himself in. If he's really a
Paulaholic, as Ezra Levant might say, he should have the self-discipline
to let his boss have the spotlight.