Ordinarily, one hesitates to encourage musicians to take themselves too
seriously. But in Steven Page's case, it's sort of endearing.
Since the Barenaked Ladies burst on to the scene in the early 1990s,
there's always been an ambitious side to their co-frontman - and
normally, it pops up on a couple of tracks per album. But like the rest
of his bandmates, Page has mostly played the clown, especially since the
U.S. breakthrough of 1998's Stunt - driven by the ubiquitous One
Week - pigeonholed the band as a sort of novelty act, albeit one with
unusual longevity.
So if Page - now into his mid-thirties, with three kids and a healthy
social conscience - is going slightly toward the other extreme, we
should probably cut him some slack.
The Toronto native's first non-BNL outing, a collaboration with
long-time songwriting partner Stephen Duffy (with whom Page has penned
some of BNL's comparatively weightier work), is nothing if not mature.
Its title - The Vanity Project - is virtually its only nod to whimsy;
Page is otherwise in full singer-songwriter mode, forsaking his poppier
instincts to serve up reflective and understated tunes aimed more at
establishing credibility than getting radio play.
"There were songs that we recorded that were probably lighter or more
poppy, ones that are more uptempo, that may surface at some time," he
says, holed up in a Toronto hotel room. "But we thought it was pretty
important to come up with a unified tone for this record."
Naturally, Page offers the standard explanation for any long-time band
member going solo: It's necessary for the group to stay strong. "In
order to want to keep collaborating with the same people, you have to do
other things," he contends. "Most artists of any kind don't collaborate
with the same four guys their entire career."
But in his case, there's something more to it. Clearly a little
frustrated with the niche BNL finds itself in, he's quite obviously
trying to win over discriminating fans outside the band's base.
The crowd that might appreciate some of BNL's more subtle offerings, he
suggests, can be turned off by the band's image, its radio-friendly hits
and the comedy act that competes with the music at his shows. Page
believes he has more in common with those folks than they'd think, and he's out to prove
it.
"I have no aspirations for [The Vanity Project] to compete with the
success of the Barenaked Ladies commercially," he says. "But I've always
had a sense that there are people who share musical tastes with me who'd
probably like a lot of the Barenaked Ladies' music if they allowed
themselves.
"For me, this'll be a success if it's brought a new audience, or an old
audience back - people who thought that perhaps we weren't for them
anymore."
There's another upside to branching out, too. An outspoken activist
who's campaigned for NDP leader Jack Layton, Page is experimenting with
inserting his political views into his music.
The new disc's most striking track (and, ironically, its poppiest) is
Wilted Rose - an offering that inserts Pierre Trudeau into the chorus
and finds the singer questioning his faith in his country.
The song, he says, was prompted by the events surrounding 2001's Free
Trade Area of the Americas summit in Quebec City. "I had a lot of
friends who went to peacefully demonstrate and were treated like shit,"
he says. "Just watching it on TV, I was saying, 'What's the difference
anymore?' That's the question. Why am I here?
"There was a point where I thought, 'OK, are we just the U.S. with worse
weather?' But I think that was also definitely a wake-up call for me to
start engaging."
The guy who once wore his Scarborough residence as a badge of honour is
clearly warming to dissent.
"I'm frustrated, and I think one of the things I'm always frustrated by
is Canadians' desire to beat their chests and say 'we're so great'
because we have gay marriage or something. There are still fundamental
issues all over this country - economic issues and political issues and
environmental issues and so on - that we should be embarrassed about.
We can't just rest on our laurels all the time."
Nor, it seems, can Page. Self-consciously mature, The Vanity Project may
not be everything it sets out to be. But laurels be damned, there are
signs that at long last, the serious artist within him is bubbling to
the surface.